Stepping into a leadership role comes with big responsibilities—one of the most important being evaluating your team fairly. Performance reviews shape careers, influence promotions, and impact morale. But bias—often unintentional—can creep in, affecting how we assess and develop employees.
As a new manager, recognizing bias early can help you build trust, foster growth, and ensure your evaluations are fair and effective. Here’s what to watch for and how to fix it:
Common Biases in Performance Reviews
🔹 Recency Bias – Overemphasizing recent events rather than evaluating the full performance period. 💡 Fix it: Keep ongoing notes throughout the year, not just before review time.
🔹 Halo/Horns Effect – Letting one standout trait (positive or negative) overshadow the entire evaluation. 💡 Fix it: Focus on multiple competencies, not just one strong or weak area.
🔹 Similarity Bias – Rating employees higher because they share similar backgrounds, work styles, or personalities. 💡 Fix it: Use standardized criteria to ensure fairness across all employees.
🔹 Leniency or Severity Bias – Being overly generous or overly critical based on personal tendencies rather than actual performance. 💡 Fix it: Compare evaluations across teams to check for inconsistencies.
🔹 Gender & Cultural Bias – Expecting different behaviors based on stereotypes (e.g., viewing assertiveness differently in men vs. women). 💡 Fix it: Challenge assumptions and ensure feedback is based on measurable outcomes.
How New Managers Can Ensure Fair Evaluations
✅ Use Clear, Objective Criteria – Define success based on measurable outcomes, not personal impressions.
✅ Gather Multiple Perspectives – Incorporate peer and 360-degree feedback to reduce individual bias.
✅ Check for Patterns – Are certain employees consistently rated lower or higher without clear justification?
✅ Encourage Self-Assessment – Employees often provide valuable insights into their growth and contributions.
✅ Ask for Feedback on Your Reviews – As a new manager, learning from experienced leaders can help refine your approach.
✅ Train Yourself on Bias Awareness – The more you recognize bias, the better you can mitigate it.
Your Leadership Starts Here
Fair evaluations lead to stronger teams, better development opportunities, and a workplace where everyone feels valued. As a new manager, setting the right foundation now will shape your leadership for years to come.